There's something that has been puzzling me for a while now... Why are women so much more incompetent at golf than men?
Take a look at the USGA's handicap chart for men and women:
With my 17 handicap, I'm among the top 12% female golfers, but if I were a man with that handicap I would be among the top 62%, so I'd really be quite average :P
Now why, why, why do we women collectively suck at this game??? Of course there are brilliant female players (as well as plenty of lousy male players ;), but if you look at the average female player, it's just dismal! I think I read somewhere that the average female score is... 108!!! Ouch.
I just read a very interesting article from Gwladys Nocera's coach (G. Nocera is a French female player who's a star on the European LPGA tour) who mentions a few things :
I would add my own thoughts to it:
So ok, we're not super good. But we can improve. I had never played any ball sport! I sucked at sports when I was in school! But three years ago, my first coach told me that I'll be in the top 2% of female golfers and that it will take 10 years. That means a 10-handicap in 7 years!! Easy :P For sure I'll get there if I continue being dedicated to this game like I've been in the past three years. And I'm pretty sure that all women can do the same if they put some effort into it :)
In the meantime, honestly, I much prefer playing in the company of men because they're often more inspiring than the women I meet on golf courses. Being part of the SFGT with the guys is also a strong incentive to improve!! You guys help me become a better player :)
Comments (26) | |
|
cogolfer1
7/12/2010 11:08:46 AM Nice read |
|
HIGH_LANDER
10/16/2009 11:51:45 AM WOW,COME ON LADIES.. |
|
Sylla
9/25/2009 4:52:44 PM Stina Stenberg gave the following tip a few months ago: "A reader once sent me this formula to calculate a player's ideal course yardage, and I love it: Multiply the average distance you hit your 27-degree club (typically your 5-iron) by 36; the total you get is a good distance for you to play from in yards." Now according to this formula, I'm playing a course that is way too long for me! Since I hit my 5-hybrid roughly 130 yards, I should be playing a 4,680 yard course. The course I usually play is 5,200+ (mind you, there's NO course that's only 4,680 yards from the reds. They're always much longer). And I'm a long player who can hit my driver 190 yards on average. Can you imagine a woman who hits it only 150!! Now a male friend of mine doesn't play a lot, but scores in the 80s from the whites. He is very tall and athletic and hits his 5-iron 200 yards. According to her formula he should be playing a 7000+ yard course! When he plays a 6,000 yard course, he actually plays a course that is 1,000 yards less than what he should be playing. So there NO way we can compare our scores! We're simply not playing the same game because of that distance difference. |
|
cogolfer1
9/16/2009 5:18:01 PM I actually think it's all in a women's swing. If you notice, when women are in their downswing they have a very slow speed going to the ball. Men seem to really whack it, which gives them that key distance Nocera's coach talked about. |
|
pjcedog
9/16/2009 4:29:27 PM Men grow up learning to hit things, all kinds of things, baseballs, each other...they just have more of a tendency to understand how to hit a ball hard. I used to see the same thing in karate classes, the men even the boys, who are no bigger than the smallest woman in the class sometimes have no problem learning to break boards. Hitting stuff and breaking it is natural for males I guess, women have to really work at it, they just don't get it. It is not because they are not strong enough, because some are more than strong enough, it is just a different mindset or attitude toward the type of power and aggressiveness that is required. |
|
ricckkster49
9/16/2009 2:29:53 PM I think incompetent is too strong a word, especially when combined with "brilliant." My personal opinion is that there are some golf courses that are too hard for men!! The handicap system is supposed to even those things out (provided you are honest). As we have mentioned previously, there are some men who consistently play from the blues or blacks when they should be playing from the white. I remain firm on reviewing the course length of the course you are playing (whether man or woman) and play the appropriate tees, or if man or woman bulk up...... |
|
mickchild
9/16/2009 11:25:06 AM Those are all great points. I also think that women are not as ultra-competitive as men (generally speaking, of course), which is what drives most of us golfers to want to be better. Most women I know simply don't care. I see it when we're watching sports too. I'm about to have a heart attack over a Dolphins loss while my wife just says, "oh, well," and starts making dinner. Men attack all these issues with absolute passion while women just see it as childish. |
|
dday39
9/16/2009 8:24:14 AM I think the length thing has a lot to do with it. For a while even guys on Tour had the mentality that they'd rather hit it 300 yards and take their chances rather than hit it 230 in the fairway and play from there. |
|
72Wannabe
9/16/2009 8:02:54 AM Sylla, maybe men are just better liars (lower handicaps)!!! :) |
|
GregRycerz
9/16/2009 8:01:50 AM I think another reason that there are more men than women that excel at golf is because its not a team sport. Women are very social and work extremely well together in teams. Just look at soccer (or football if you prefer), volleyball, cheerleading, etc. Another thing is exposure. Most of the ladies on the LPGA have the same story, "I started playing golf with my dad." Its up to us dads to get our girls golfing and increase those numbers!! ;^) |
|
PinHunter
9/16/2009 7:45:35 AM Great post Sylla. I found this very interesting and I agree with most of the points you listed as the difference especially the point that Gwladys Nocera's coach makes about men being more educated in ball sports to start with. It looks like we picked up golf at about the same time (3 years ago). When I started my raw scores without practice or experience in the game were right around 100. If you look at my profile now after three years of golf being my primary sport in the summer my average score is 84.4. That just only 15 strokes better. I guess my point is, even though your scores are higher at approx. the same amount of time learning the game (and I think there are a number of reasons listed above that may speak to that). Are we progressing at the same level of improvement? Scores aside that's what's important. I bet you're on that pace or better. Ps: Your game seems to be coming together nicely as of late too Sylla. Congrats |
|
Duckhunter
9/15/2009 4:38:58 PM You asked, it's the brain. it take a lot to keep your mind on the game every shot, women can not. their brain goes 100mph and is all over the place all the time. Sorry Sylla women just don't have what it takes to be good at golf, they think to much. |
|
Sylla
9/15/2009 3:30:52 PM When I tag this post, it automatically capitalizes the word "MEN", but it doesn't do the same for "women". LOL. |